||South Africa: SA to Benefit from Economic Pact with EU
||Tuesday, July 22, 2014
Citizen Engagement, Internet Governance
||Jul 22, 2014
After ten years of preparations and negotiations, SADC and the EU initialled the EPA last Tuesday. The initialling of the agreement signals that the negotiations are concluded.
Speaking to media, Minister Davies said the timing is significant because it pre-empts the 1 October 2014 deadline imposed by the EU, after which Botswana, Namibia and Swaziland would have lost preferential access to the EU market for their exports of beef, fish and sugar, on which their economies heavily rely.
The talks -- known as the Makgobakgoba dialogue -- have been difficult, with South Africa objecting to the EU’s demands for a prohibition on export taxes, for most favourable nation status, and what it saw as a lack of give and take, especially over more access for its agricultural and agro-processed goods as well as the final wording on export taxes and geographic indicators.
Minister Davis said they objected because they sought an outcome that would preserve coherence in the Southern African Customs Union (SACU) in terms of maintaining the common external tariff that is at the core of the union.
He said they sought to improve access to the EU market over and above what they currently obtain under the bilateral Trade, Development and Cooperation Agreement (TDCA), specifically access for South Africa’s agricultural products.
Minister Davies said being stubborn has paid up, as the outcome was more favourable for South Africa than the EU’s original offer.
“In trade negotiations, you have to learn to say no and this is what we did because we did not approve with other elements of the agreement. This then opened up negotiations and we tend to benefit from the outcome.”
The outcome, he added, is an improvement on South Africa’s bilateral TDCA, which came into full force in 2012.
He said the EPA was more favourable for South Africa than the EU’s original offer, as they have gained more access for agricultural goods, while the EU had won recognition for geographic indicators.
Improved market access
South Africa has achieved improved market access for 32 agricultural products, with a significant improvement in access to the EU market for wine (110 million litres duty free), sugar (150 000 tons duty free) and ethanol (80 000 tons duty free). There also improved access for exports of flowers, some dairy, fruit and fruit products.
"The EPA allows for greater harmonisation with SACU, some improved access for South African wine, sugar and fruit products, and allows some policy space for export taxes compared to the TDCA, as well as some additional agricultural safeguards,” said Minister Davies.
In return, the EU wanted recognition for several of its wines, cheeses, speciality meats and beers, while South Africa was pushing for recognition of its honeybush and rooibos teas, Karoo lamb and some of its wines.
But outcomes with regards to geographic indicators, according to the minister, will not affect the product names currently being used by producers in South Africa, as they have established a mechanism to address non-tariff barriers that inhibit trade in wine.
In terms of the process and timeframe for entry into force, the agreement will first be subjected to a two-month legal vetting process.
“Thereafter, the agreement can be presented to Cabinet and, if approved, submitted to the Parliament for ratification,” said Minister Davies.
Once ratified, the agreement may be signed, and it will enter into force once all parties have concluded their own respective national approval processes.
According to Minister Davies, the timeframe for this process is likely to be around eight months.
He said negotiating the agreement was a major achievement for the region, adding that it paves the legal basis for the relationship between African countries participating in a future tripartite free trade agreement and Europe.
The negotiations were between the EU and the five members of the Southern African Customs Union (Sacu) plus Mozambique and Angola.