A controversial state secrets bill is expected to become law in Japan this week despite objections from a broadening coalition who say the legislation is being rushed through the Diet.
Lawyers, journalists, religious leaders and a Nobel physicist are among a growing group of opponents who think the act is worryingly vague and gives too much power to the government.
And an opinion poll released Monday showed increasing disquiet among voters over a law that would dramatically ramp up punishments for people convicted of giving away state secrets—an elastic category that can be expanded by ministers or bureaucrats to cover a wide range of information.
Conservative Prime Minister Shinzo Abe says the bill is necessary to plug a notoriously leaky government machine, which prevents chief ally the United States sharing intelligence.
The powerful lower house of the Diet passed the bill last week and Abe has vowed to push it through the upper chamber by Friday, provoking accusations of steamrollering.
A survey by the liberal Asahi Shimbun showed 61% of voters think the pace of the bill’s passage is “problematic”, with more than three-quarters of those polled saying the law would create new secrets, rather than better safeguarding existing ones.
The survey of around 2,000 households comes after a string of influential groups have expressed opposition, including The Japan Federation of Bar Associations and more than 2,000 academics, among them 2008 Nobel physicist Toshihide Masukawa.
Clergy have also joined the debate, with Takao Takeda, a Buddhist monk and secretary of Shukyosha Kyujo-no-wa, a multi-faith grouping, saying the bill had echoes of Japan’s tragic march towards war last century.
“The bill being discussed now seems very similar to the Public Order Preservation Law” enacted in 1925, which enabled Imperial Japan to arrest anyone who voiced protest against the then government, Takeda said.
“It is important to protect people’s rights to know given our history and the way information was hidden in World War II and the fact that the government was not very open in the face of the nuclear crisis” triggered by the huge tsunami of 2011.
Under the proposals, information related to defense, diplomacy, counter-intelligence and counter-terrorism can all be classified as a state secret, at the behest of politicians.
There is no provision for independent oversight of the process, leading to claims that inconvenient truths or news of bumbling by an already-opaque government could be declared off-limits.
“It is a threat to democracy,” Keiichi Kiriyama, editorial writer of the Tokyo Shimbun, told foreign journalists on Monday.
The legislation would “have a chilling effect on public servants who could become wary about giving the information” sought by journalists, he said.
Tsutomu Shimizu of the Japan Federation of Bar Associations said “civil activities and the expression of individual opinions would be included in the definition of terrorism in this bill… As lawyers, we are concerned” about the scope of this law.
Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga told reporters at a regular press briefing on Monday the government “will answer questions” over the bill during the current Diet session.